I've always heard that the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different outcome. It is clear to me that I have absolutely lost my mind when it comes to a "grove" of Autumn Cherries that I planted 6 years ago in front of the garden.
It all started when I got a vision of a path leading to the garden gate (which, by the way, we don't even use on the regular) winding through a grove of beautiful, pink blossoms. I debated for a while on whether to plant crabapples or cherries but eventually settled on Autumn Cherries because they can have a small bloom in the fall, and who doesn't want a second bloom? What I didn't consider, because we had not lived here long enough to learn, was that this area of the field can stay very, very wet. And cherries do not like wet feet.

It all began on the wrong foot because we started by ordering very small cherries to plant and made the mistake, for one single night, of leaving them out in the field unprotected. The deer immediately found their tender young leaves and tore them apart. A few were not savable and the ones that were, to this day, look a little mangled. The ones that lived that is. Below is a poor quality photo but it shows how small the trees were and there's even a deer in the background!

You see, I've lost track of how many cherries I've had to replace. I only remember which ones are original by their deformed structure, the rest I'm not sure how many times I've replaced. As you can see in the second photo, I now have trees of all different sizes and shapes. It is clear this was a bad spot for them. But I can't seem to learn the lesson because I've got a vision and a pattern going and I can't come to terms with the fact that I'm going to have a random smattering of trees in front of the garden instead of a precise grid!
All this to say, we lost another tree this year. It's been an unbelievably wet winter and spring and, frankly, we are sopping wet over here. Our clay soil, with shale underneath, just can't shed the water efficiently. So my favorite cherry, the first one we see and the one with the best shape, tried to push out some blossoms but just failed to live. I imagine her roots rotted, we will know when we dig her up. I've taken it hard, like a bit silly hard.
It's so disappointing and frustrating and I think I'm giving it more meaning than it deserves, but I suppose I will not replant it, finally giving in to the lesson I should have learned years ago.
P.S. Two of the original cherries, that actually look awful, turned out not to even be Autumn Cherries! Instead of beautiful pink blossoms, they are white which makes it clear this was an ill-fated project from the start!